Lt. Governor Dan Patrick
Dear Mr. Patrick,
I am a woman who was in a compromising situation recently. I really really needed to go, and the women’s bathroom was locked so I used the men’s restroom instead. Would your proposal for a “bathroom bill” here in Texas require me to be arrested?
I find it strange that you and so many other Texas lawmakers are fixated on this issue. When I went into the men’s restroom, I knocked first, went in to use a stall and closed the door behind me. There was plenty of privacy; I didn’t threaten anyone and I didn’t feel threatened. I just did my business, washed my hands and went on my way. Isn’t this what most Texans do? Why on earth has using the bathroom become a political issue?
Last month, Texas senators passed SB 6, even though many Texas businesses argued against it and believe these kinds of laws will hurt Texas’ reputation and our state’s economics.
Requiring folks to use the gendered bathroom in line with their birth certificate is bizarre in so many ways.
Who is going to be there to check birth certificates? What do you propose they should do about me, pressured and stymied by a locked door? What about all the non-Texans who know very well this is a non-issue but come here to find themselves accosted by bathroom police? Will our businesses suffer? (Besides I thought Republicans liked business! Why aren’t you respecting their voices in this debate?)
This week, the State Affairs Committee will debate the House version of a bathroom bill, HB 2899. Have you read this bill? The wording is highly problematic and might very well give local entities power to discriminate against transgendered citizens, veterans and the elderly. State legislators should be protecting the rights of all Texans, not creating more loopholes for schools or municipalities to victimize those who are already vulnerable.
I assume you must be proud of your highly touted Operation One Million Voices campaign. I suppose you think this is in line with “Christian” values: preserving purity and all that.
But as a Christian minister, I believe this effort of yours is wrong headed, unkind and unchristian.
I get that you don’t understand the experience of transgendered people, but just because you are Lt. Governor doesn’t mean you get to name their experience for them.
In fact, your legal, moral, ethical and Christian obligation is to protect these misunderstood people from those who would persecute and harm them.
They are the fragile ones in this scenario; not you.
Have you met Kai Shappley or heard her story? She is a kindergartener, a beautiful little girl, one of God’s precious children. Her mom, Kimberly, is a very conservative Republican and a pious Christian. Even so, Kai has taught her mom – and many more of us – that some life experiences do not fit into our cookie cutter expectations. When that happens, our Christianity calls us to offer grace. When that happens, our humanity demands that we live in love.
Remember these core Christian values?
Love others as you love yourself?
Do unto others as you would have them do unto you?
Surely you learned this in Sunday School. Have you forgotten such deep and obvious truth?
Mr. Patrick, please leave these poor people alone. They have enough to deal with already.
Please return to authentic Conservative values and allow people to live their lives without government interference.
You too have enough to deal with. Please get back to governing and stop using governmental powers to persecute some of our most vulnerable citizens. Texas has plenty of other issues you need to be working on. With all due respect, get to it.
Rev. Charlotte Vaughan Coyle
Charlotte Vaughan Coyle lives in Paris TX and blogs about intersections of faith, culture and politics on her website and Intersections Facebook page. She is national secretary for Coffee Party USA and contributes regularly to the Join the Coffee Party Movement Facebook page.