Is it Really the End of White Christian America?

I am a White Christian American born and raised. So it’s been an interesting experience to read Robert Jones’ book: The End of White Christian America.

Jones, CEO of Public Religion Research Institute (PRRI), begins with an obituary:

White Christian America is survived by two principal branches of descendants: a mainline Protestant family residing primarily in the Northeast and upper Midwest and an evangelical Protestant family living mostly in the South. Plans for a public memorial service have not been announced. 

He then tracks the history of White Christianity in America, from the founding of the nation all the way through the recent election in which 81% of White Evangelicals voted for Donald Trump.

(Black Christian America and Catholic America both have a different story. The work Jones tackles is challenging enough as he unpacks the complicated family tree of us Protestant White folks. But the analysis he offers about White Protestant Christians is important, critical even, in order to understand our current political climate.)

White Christian America was a given at this nation’s founding. Of course there were a handful of Deists among the Founders but almost everyone was some sort of Christian. Some were pious, others were nominal; some were active practitioners while others wore the name simply because of the comfort of its cultural pervasiveness. The culture of the day was White and Protestant. The leaders of the day were Free Male Land Owners.

So the question: “Is America a Christian nation?” never has been an appropriate framing of the situation. Yes – many of the Founders were some sort of Christian and often their thinking and writing reflected that orientation. Yes – America has been majority Christian for its entire lifetime. But No – the First Amendment makes it clear that, even if there is a religious majority within the nation, the federal government is to be neutral, not establishing (nor disestablishing) any particular religion. And Yes – ongoing amendments and common law have unpacked the First Amendment so the Constitution has been evolving across America’s entire lifetime.

Robert Jones outlines the historic divisions between the two major representatives of White Christian America: Protestant Mainline Christianity and Evangelical Christianity. He does this through the lens of three critical issues: politics, race and family. I will skim through his analysis of White Evangelical Christianity.

Politics in White Christian America

The marriage of White Evangelicals to the Republican Party is a fairly recent development. Jones identifies how a “White Christian Strategy” arose out of the “Southern Strategy” of the 1960’s when White Southern Democrats flocked to the GOP in droves because of their disdain for the Civil Rights Movement. Jerry Falwell and the Moral Majority tapped in to this “Great White Shift” and the Christian Right became a political force. In 1976, Falwell’s “I Love America” rallies were filled to overflowing with people who wanted political solutions to their targeted issues of abortion, feminism and homosexuality. Heirs of this religious-political movement continued to gain steam during the 1990’s, but during the 2000’s, there were numerous scandals, stumbles, divisions and declines within White Christian America. This led to the election of President Barack Obama in 2008.

Just a few months into the Obama presidency, however, the Tea Party emerged. There have been numerous explanations for this movement but Robert Jones cites PRRI data that clearly links the Tea Party to the Religious Right. It wasn’t just about taxes and small government like they claimed; rather objections to abortion and gay marriage dominated the Tea Party movement, demonstrating to Jones that the Tea Party was “another revival of White Christian America.”

Robert Jones added a chapter to this book after the 2016 election, analyzing the fact that 81% of White Evangelical Christians voted for Trump. Jones remains convinced that the End of White Christian America really has arrived, and he sees the current situation not as a revival but rather as the last gasps of a growing minority. White Christian America has been in power for 239 years and we should not expect it to go quietly into the night.

White Christian America and the Family

Jones shows how successful the Christian Right was in its early efforts to outlaw gay marriage based on its commitment to “traditional family values.” Numerous states passed laws and even Constitutional amendments that outlawed marriage equality in the years leading up to the 2015 tumultuous Supreme Court decision. Since that ruling, a variety of religious freedom issues continue to arise that demonstrate the ongoing resistance from the Religious Right.

Racism in White Christian America

In my opinion, the most powerful chapter in Jones’ book is chapter 5. Race: Desegregating White Christian America. In recent years, when young Black men and women were being killed in epidemic numbers by police officers across the nation, President Obama said: “This has been a slow-rolling crisis. This has been going on for a long time. This is not new, and we shouldn’t pretend that it’s new.”

But for White America, it did feel new. PRRI asked Black and White Americans about their perception of police violence.

“Is this part of a larger pattern or are these isolated incidents?”

The perception gap was huge.

Three quarters of Black Americans see a broad pattern while less than half of White Americans do. (The numbers barely changed over the two decades since Rodney King.) But among WCA, the gap was even larger. 74% of Black Americans see a problem but only 26% of White Evangelical Christians do. We look at the same world and we see things entirely differently.

The Ongoing Grief Process

Robert Jones concludes his work with an interesting discussion of the grief process. He says the loss of power, privilege and predominance for White Christian America is evoking the classic stages of grief: Denial. Anger. Bargaining. Depression. And then finally Acceptance.

Jones specifically mentions David Gushee, an Evangelical ethicist, who is nudging conservative Christians to accept the end of White Christian America. But it is an acceptance tinged with hope.

Gushee makes the following appeal to his fellow evangelicals: “We have to grow up—past conspiracy theories, demagoguery, single-issue voting, partisan seductions, mudslinging, and God-and-country conflations and confusions.”

Naming reasons for decline, addressing the causes and finding new pathways forward is the only way through the current dilemma for White Christian America. Gushee is one my recent favorite writers as he seeks to carve out a center space for conversation and collaboration with Non-White, Non-Protestant, Non-Christian America.

Is This Really the End?

I am a White Christian American born and raised. My own path has led me out of fundamentalism, through conservatism and now into liberalism. (Whatever all those fuzzy terms mean!) My own theological studies and my pastoral work with congregations of Christians across the conservative to liberal spectrum has convinced me that White Christian America needs to die.

Too much of what we see represented as Christianity in this nation is an empty shell, a hollow structure.

As a Christian minister, I believe the Church needs to find its way back to the authentic witness of the Christ whose name we wear. If we don’t live as Christ-people, then we ought to die. As an American, I believe our nation will benefit from a rebirth of Christianity and the transformation of American Christians: White, Black, Brown, Conservative, Mainline, Gay, Straight, Rich, Poor, Republican, Democrat, Independent.

When we Christians begin to “treat others as we want to be treated,” then America will be kinder. When we Christians begin to “love our neighbors as we love ourselves,” then America will be stronger. When we Christians begin to “empty ourselves” in humble service to others, then America will be greater.

So (as T.S. Elliot said) the end can be the beginning.

 

 

Robert P. Jones, The End of White Christian America. Simon & Schuster. Kindle Edition.

 

Charlotte Vaughan Coyle lives in Paris TX and blogs about intersections of faith, culture and politics on her website and Intersections Facebook page. She is national secretary for Coffee Party USA and contributes regularly to the Join the Coffee Party Movement Facebook page.

Charlotte is an ordained minister within the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) and also blogs about Scripture from a progressive Christian approach in her Living in The Story Musings.

 

Published by

Charlotte Vaughan Coyle

Charlotte Vaughan Coyle

Charlotte Vaughan Coyle lives in Paris TX and blogs about intersections of faith, culture and politics on her website and Intersections Facebook page. She is national president for Coffee Party USA and contributes regularly to the Join the Coffee Party Movement Facebook page.

Charlotte is an ordained minister within the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) and also blogs about Scripture from a progressive Christian approach in her Living in The Story Musings.

13 thoughts on “Is it Really the End of White Christian America?”

  1. As a descendant of first Christians from southwest India, I have this to say: most white evangelicals are white and their allegiance is to whiteness, but they are not Christian. Calling them Christian and letting them into India to preach the gospel was an abomination in the past, is an abomination now and will be an abomination in the future. If India accepts missionaries, it should only accept non-white missionaries from the US and there are plenty of them! What the support for Trump proved was that white evangelicals, particularly the white women, worship Trump and whiteness, not Jesus. The same can be said of white female supporters of Roy Moore in Alabama.

  2. With the growth of the far right ultra conservative evangelical form of Christianity , I have frequently been reluctant to admit that I am a Christian. Is this one reason for the demise of Christianity? That we’re ashamed to be connected to the very vocal evangelicals who think they speak for all Christians? ?

    1. Great question Joyce! You may be on to something. I know quite a few people who have given up on Christianity because of the extremism of the Right. Then on the other hand, others have been discouraged by irrelevance from the Left. The people of God have cycled through faithfulness and unfaithfulness for millennia. Both the Hebrew and the Christian Scriptures speak of a “faithful remnant.” Evidently we humans default to form instead of substance on a regular basis.

      It’s not just progressive Christians who are frustrated and embarrassed by the misuse of Christ’s name. I also know some faithful Evangelicals who also are hesitant to use the name “Evangelical” because of the extremist hijack. I hope more and more of us do the soul searching that is required for our day so that we may speak up and stand up for a more authentic Christianity and offer a bolder witness of love, welcome and compassion than we have in the past. Thanks for reading and thanks for the conversation! Peace…

  3. Interestingly enough, I awoke this morning with the thought that we have replaced the Golden Rule in this country with Do Unto Others, Its OK. How sad that so many white Christian Americans seem to have adopted this attitude.

  4. I have to agree with Mr. Jones in fact I do agree with everything he said. I hope others will read this article and I think I may read the book!

  5. Interesting article. I’m an atheist, but also a preacher’s kid. My father was a very left-leaning Disciples of Christ minister. And Soutgern. I’ve been appalled at what often passes as Christian doctrine among a very vocal segment of the Christian Right. It seems to have nothing whatsoever to do with the teachings of Jesus.

    1. I’m grateful for how Disciples and UCC and so many other Progressive Christians are speaking out and stepping up during these days. I’m grateful for the collaborations of Christians and non-Christians during these odd days. We need to find allies and do what we can together. Thanks for the conversation, Susan. Peace…

  6. It’s so nice to be read out of Christianity so easily as a catholic. Do the Eastern Orthox, Greek , Russian and Copt, count?

    1. I know that must feel very odd, Richard. And insulting. But Jones had his hands full in this particular book addressing the wide range of American Prostestantism and how it has influenced American politics. He also did not deal much with Black Protestants in this analysis. I encourage you to read the book; Robert Jones has great respect for the Roman Catholic Church and has an extended discussion about the election of JFK. Thanks for reading and thanks for the conversation. Peace…

  7. Thanks for the review. This sounds like a good read. I also recommend One Nation Under God: How Corporate America Invented Christian America by Kevin M. Kruse. It is a fascinating and detailed explanation of how a small group of extraordinarily wealthy individuals corrupted the teachings of the church to support their greedy agenda.

  8. Although I am a Unitarian Universalist I totally have followed the Christian “treat others the way you want to be treated” and “love our neighbors as ourselves.”
    We don’t have to follow or believe as other faiths do but we must respect their beliefs as long as one does not harm anyone else.

    1. Absolutely Sharon! My critique and appeal is to my fellow Christians. As a group, we need to do a better job of practicing what we preach. Peace…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *